HP EliteDesk G1a vs Apple Mac Studio M5 Max

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black

HP
62 Overall Score
vs
Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD

Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD

Apple
100 Overall Score

What Buyers Say

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black

No customer feedback yet

Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD

92 out of 100 low confidence 6 reviews

Users are overwhelmingly positive about the Mac Studio with M5 Max, praising its speed, performance in media production, and seamless Apple ecosystem integration. Several reviewers upgraded from older machines and found the performance leap significant, especially for 4K editing. The build quality and reliability are also highlighted, with one user noting their previous Mac lasted 10 years. A few mention the value of catching it on sale, given Apple's recent price increases.

Pros
  • Blazing fast performance
  • Excellent for 4K editing
  • Seamless Apple ecosystem integration
  • Reliable build quality
  • Good upgrade from older Macs
Cons
  • Pricey, especially with recent Apple hikes
  • Base storage may be limiting for large projects
👍 Performance 5
👍 Media production 3
👍 Apple ecosystem 3
👍 Build quality 2
🤔 Value for money 2
🤔 Storage 2

Scores

Business
HP
64
Apple
97
Compact
HP
66
Apple
97
Developer
HP
61
Apple
96
Home Office
HP
62
Apple
95
Workstation
HP
52
Apple
90
Creator
HP
26
Apple
74
Ai Llm
HP
24
Apple
73
Gaming
HP
14
Apple
51

Specifications

HP EliteDesk G1aApple Mac Studio M5 Max
Processor
CPU*AMD Ryzen AI 5 340Apple M5 Max★
CPU Multi-Core Score
19,659
57,732
Cores618★
Frequency2.0 GHz★—
L3 Cache8 MB★—
Graphics
GPU*AMD Radeon 840MApple (32-Core)★
GPU Benchmark Score
3,750
22,130
Typeintegratedintegrated
VRAM—36 GB★
VRAM Type—System Shared
Memory & Storage
RAM16 GB36 GB★
RAM GenerationDDR5DDR5
Storage 1512 GB1 TB★
Storage 1 TypeNVMe SSDNVMe SSD
Build
Form Factorminimini
PSU90W480W★
Weight1.35 kg2.70 kg
Connectivity
USB-C Ports26★
USB Ports4★2
ThunderboltUSB4Thunderbolt 5 x 4
HDMI1x HDMI 2.1 Output1x HDMI 2.1
DisplayPort2x DisplayPort 2.1 Output—
Wi-FiWi-Fi 6EWi-Fi 7★
BluetoothBluetooth 5.3★Bluetooth 6.0
EthernetGigabit Ethernet10 GbE
System
OSWindows 11 PromacOS

Pros & Cons

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black

  • Strong port selection (76th percentile)
  • Strong reliability (70th percentile)

Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD

  • Strong reliability (99th percentile)99th %ile
  • Strong cpu (96th percentile)96th %ile
  • Strong user sentiment (95th percentile)95th %ile
  • Strong ram (92nd percentile)92nd %ile

Pricing

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black is $1,460 cheaper (2.1x less).

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black0.047score per dollar
vs
Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD0.036score per dollar

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black offers 1.3x better value for money

HP EliteDesk G1a 2024, Ryzen AI 5 340, 16GB, 512GB SSD, Black

Apple Mac Studio M5 Max, 36GB, 1TB SSD

Verdict

★ Winner: Apple Mac Studio M5 Max

Scores 100 overall, wins 8 of 8 usage categories and 11 of 26 specs.

Apple Mac Studio M5 Max Better at:

Ai LlmGamingCompactCreatorBusinessDeveloperHome OfficeWorkstation

Also Consider