MSI Katana Thin 15 vs Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max

MSI Katana Thin 15 2024, Core i9-14900HX, 32GB, 2TB SSD, RTX 5070, Black

MSI Katana Thin 15 2024, Core i9-14900HX, 32GB, 2TB SSD, RTX 5070, Black

MSI
71 総合スコア
vs
Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max 2024, 64GB, 4TB SSD, Silver

Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max 2024, 64GB, 4TB SSD, Silver

Apple
98 総合スコア

The MacBook Pro M4 Max is the better all-around machine, scoring 99 vs 71 overall, but the MSI Katana 15 HX is no slouch where it counts for gamers. You're looking at a $3,099+ premium ultrabook against a budget gaming laptop that actually edges it out in raw CPU and GPU benchmarks. The MacBook wins on build quality, portability, and storage, but the MSI gives you a 165Hz panel and a discrete RTX 5070 for way less cash.

MSI Katana Thinがおすすめ:

Get the MSI Katana 15 HX if you're a gamer or budget-conscious power user who wants desktop-class CPU and GPU performance with a high-refresh 165Hz screen without dropping MacBook money.

Apple MacBook Proがおすすめ:

Get the MacBook Pro M4 Max if you're a creative pro or developer who wants a dead-silent, featherweight machine with 64GB of RAM, 4TB of storage, and a gorgeous Mini-LED display, and you don't mind paying a serious premium for it.

主な違い

  • The MacBook Pro M4 Max scores 99 overall vs the MSI Katana 15 HX's 71, but the MSI actually wins on raw gaming performance with an 87 vs 60 gaming score thanks to its discrete RTX 5070 and 165Hz panel.
  • The MacBook packs 64GB of RAM and 4TB of storage vs the MSI's 32GB and 2TB, which matters big time for video editors and developers juggling huge projects.
  • The MacBook weighs 1.60 kg vs the MSI's 2.25 kg, and it has 3 USB-C ports vs just 1 on the MSI, so portability and connectivity are no contest.
  • The MSI's Intel Core i9 14900HX with 24 cores edges out the M4 Max's 16 cores in multi-core benchmarks (43,922 vs 43,903), but the MacBook's integrated GPU is more efficient than the MSI's discrete one for everyday tasks.
  • Customer sentiment on the MacBook is glowing with a 95/100 score and zero significant gripes, while the MSI sits at 4.8/5 from just 10 reviews, so long-term reliability data is thinner on the MSI side.

購入者の声

MSI Katana Thin 15 2024, Core i9-14900HX, 32GB, 2TB SSD, RTX 5070, Black

まだレビューがありません

Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max 2024, 64GB, 4TB SSD, Silver

95 100点中 信頼度: 低 8 件のレビュー

MacBook Pro M4 Maxは、重い写真やビデオ編集タスクを簡単に処理できるパワフルなワークホースとして広く賞賛されています。ユーザーは、スムーズなパフォーマンス、高速なファイル処理、Appleエコシステムとのシームレスな統合を強調しています。確認済みの購入者は、特にMaxではなくProを選ぶことで優れたコストパフォーマンスを一貫して指摘し、B&Hのカスタマーサービスと配送プロセスを称賛しています。

長所
  • 重いタスクに対する強力なパフォーマンス
  • 写真・ビデオ編集のスムーズな処理
  • 高速ファイルインポート・エクスポート
  • Appleエコシステムとのシームレスな統合
  • 優れたコストパフォーマンス
短所
  • 重大な欠点は言及されていません
👍 Performance 5
👍 Photo video editing 3
👍 Apple ecosystem 2
👍 Value for money 2
👍 Customer service 3
👍 Shipping process 2

スコア

Entertainment
MSI
74
Apple
98
Developer
MSI
83
Apple
98
Business
MSI
68
Apple
97
Compact
MSI
64
Apple
93
Student
MSI
69
Apple
93
Gaming
MSI
89
Apple
61
Ai Llm
MSI
60
Apple
89
Creator
MSI
86
Apple
78

スペック

MSI Katana Thin 15Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max
Processor
CPU*Intel Core i9 14900HXApple M4 Max★
CPU Multi-Core Score
43,506
43,841
Cores24★16
Frequency4.1 GHz★—
L3 Cache36 MB★—
Graphics
GPU*NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5070★Apple (40-Core)
GPU Benchmark Score
19,137
17,798
Typediscreteintegrated★
VRAM12 GB★—
VRAM TypeGDDR7System Shared
Memory & Storage
RAM32 GB64 GB★
RAM GenerationDDR5LPDDR5
Storage 12 TB4 TB★
Storage 1 TypeNVMe SSDNVMe SSD
Display
Size15.6"14.2"
Resolution—3024 px★
PanelIPSMini-LED★
Refresh Rate165 Hz★120 Hz
Brightness—1600 nits★
Color Gamut45% NTSC100% sRGB, 95% DCI-P3
Connectivity
USB-C Ports13★
USB Ports3★—
Thunderbolt—Thunderbolt 5
HDMIHDMI 2.11x HDMI Output
Wi-FiWi-Fi 6EWi-Fi 6E
BluetoothBluetooth 5.3Bluetooth 5.3
EthernetGigabit Ethernet—
Physical
Weight1.86 kg1.60 kg★
Battery—72 Wh★
OSWindows 11 HomemacOS

長所と短所

MSI Katana Thin 15 2024, Core i9-14900HX, 32GB, 2TB SSD, RTX 5070, Black

  • Strong storage (94th percentile)94th %ile
  • Strong cpu (93rd percentile)93rd %ile
  • Strong gpu (93rd percentile)93rd %ile
  • Strong social proof (81st percentile)81st %ile
  • Below average affordability (14th percentile)14th %ile

Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max 2024, 64GB, 4TB SSD, Silver

  • Strong screen (99th percentile)99th %ile
  • Strong user sentiment (99th percentile)99th %ile
  • Strong storage (99th percentile)99th %ile
  • Strong reliability (98th percentile)98th %ile
  • Below average affordability (2nd percentile)2nd %ile

結論

★ 勝者: Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max

Scores 98 overall, wins 6 of 8 usage categories and 11 of 30 specs.

MSI Katana Thin 15 優れている点:

GamingCreator

Apple MacBook Pro 14.2" M4 Max 優れている点:

Ai LlmCompactStudentBusinessDeveloperEntertainment